MAC “Over the Top” Lipstick Review: A Deep Autumn Must-Have?

 

Sunday swatch time, Glow Girls! 💄 Let’s talk about this beauty I’ve had tucked away in my kit for a while now—MAC’s “Over the Top” lipstick. It came as part of a special set, and I wasn’t sure about it at first… but spoiler alert: she’s a keeper.

Let’s get into it:

The shade? A rich, muted mauve-rose with just enough depth to complement those of us with a Deep Autumn palette. Think polished without trying, flattering without overpowering.

💋 Finish and formula:

Now, I’ll be honest—this one leans matte, and I normally run from mattes like they’re trying to ruin my already dry lips. But I had a trick up my sleeve: I layered it over my Laneige Lip Sleeping Mask (because hydration is life), and the combo? Chef’s kiss. Without the balm, it’s too drying for my taste.

💄 Application + staying power:

Glides on smoothly enough, but unlike MAC’s classic bullet lipsticks, the staying power here isn’t as long. It fades into a pretty stain, though, which makes it great for casual days out or when you’re layering gloss on top. It’s the kind of lipstick you throw in your bag “just in case” but end up reaching for again and again.

✨ Best for:

Deep Autumn skin tones

Every day glam without the fuss

Girls who prefer a soft matte without going full desert

Final thoughts:

MAC's "Over the Top" is a pleasant surprise. It's not the star of the show, but it is the reliable understudy that delivers every time. Pair it with a moisturizing balm and she'll give you the pretty pout you're after. 

Will I repurchase? I don't think so. There are so many lipstick shades out there that I want to try.